When Public Safety and “National Security” Clash

Editor’s Note: The following article published in the Kitsap Sun on October 24th highlights the continuing struggle to guarantee the public’s right to know of potential hazards to our communities, our homes and our families. The government (and in this case the Navy) regularly overreaches in invoking “national security” in withholding records that affect the safety and health of citizens living around government facilities – in this case the naval base with the largest operational concentration of nuclear weapons in the US arsenal, Naval Base Kitsap-Bangor. Glen Milner, who is at the forefront of Ground Zero’s lawsuit challenging the Navy’s grossly deficient Environmental Impact Statement for the second explosives handling wharf at Bangor, is cited in this article.

*************************

Feds, county diverge on Bangor records

By Ed Friedrich, Kitsap Sun, Oct 24, 2015

A request for information about Naval Base Kitsap-Bangor emergency plans has spotlighted conflicts between state and federal disclosure laws.

In January, Glen Milner asked Kitsap County Emergency Management for records regarding potential consequences of a radiological accident at the submarine base and planned responses to them.

Because some of the documents were marked for official use only, the county notified the Navy in case it wanted to seek a court order to keep them from being released.

In June the U.S. attorney’s office in Seattle, representing the Navy, threatened to sue deputy prosecuting attorneys Alexis Foster and Shelley Kneip, Foster said. The Navy contends some of the documents have national security implications and should be protected.

“We’ve been informed should we release the records without their authority, permission or approval or as they requested them to be withheld or redacted, we are subject to criminal and civil prosecution,” Foster said.

Milner, a Seattle peace activist associated with Poulsbo’s Ground Zero Center for Nonviolent Action, said the public should know how to react in an emergency. Pantex, the country’s only nuclear weapons assembly and disassembly facility, for example, openly shares its emergency information on its website. It describes three levels of emergencies and what to do in each, where to listen for information, how to shelter in place, how to evacuate and where to go.

The Bangor “response plans are in place, and nobody knows anything about them, so they don’t really do anybody any good,” Milner said. “They’ve gone to the trouble of creating the plans, but they don’t want to tell anybody about them.”

Unlike Pantex, the Navy doesn’t confirm or deny there are nuclear weapons at Bangor, or anywhere else. It can’t distribute a radiological accident plan because that might imply the presence of nuclear weapons. It acknowledges, however, that the 11 submarines based there are nuclear-powered and that eight of them are each capable of carrying up to 24 ballistic missiles with multiple warheads.

The county and U.S. attorney’s office continue to release information to Milner as it’s processed, though their relationship is chafed by different disclosure laws — the Washington Public Records Act and the federal Freedom of Information Act.

FOIA-cartoon

Because the emergency response plans were created by the county and are held by the county, state law applies. Normally the county would process Milner’s request and if the feds disagreed, they could seek an injunction. Instead, the feds are making redactions and withholding records based on federal law. The county then reviews the actions to ensure they conform to state law.

“That’s a particular concern of ours and why we have to conduct a review, to ensure if (the redactions are) appropriate and permissible under state law,” Foster said.

The U.S. attorney’s office is working with Kitsap County to provide Milner “with those appropriate nonsensitive documents which the United States has consented to release,” spokeswoman Emily Langlie said.

Michele Earl-Hubbard, an expert in public records with Allied Law Group, said Milner’s request is clearly a county responsibility and covered by state law. The U.S. attorney’s office should stay out of it unless it wants to file for an injunction. Milner’s request hasn’t transpired that way, however, and at this point, for timeliness, records should go straight to him without county review, which can be performed later.

“The local agency has to provide the ‘fullest assistance’ and ‘most timely response,’ and they’re not giving that when they sit on a request for nine months,” she said.

The federal government is “almost always” overreaching when it claims records are exempt based on national security, she said.

“The reality is, almost every piece of public information has value to a terrorist. It also has value to everybody else,” she said, including an emergency plan.

“People need to know where to evacuate, not just the bureaucrats,” she said.

Milner requested similar documents from the state Department of Health, which has a radiological department. The Navy and Federal Emergency Management Agency were notified. The Health Department gave them until Oct. 30 to file for an injunction. So far, they haven’t, Milner said.

Source URL: http://www.kitsapsun.com/news/local-news/feds-county-diverge-on-bangor-records_10061951 

Share widely

“Being Arrested for Peace is an Honor”

Editor’s Note: Doug Mulholland, one of the participants in Ground Zero’s August blockade of the Bangor Trident submarine base, wrote the following report on his August experience, the subsequent court hearing and his thoughts on nonviolent civil resistance. With great thanks to all of the resisters willing to take an extra step (out into the road) for peace.   

***********************

Tuesday Oct 27th Brenda McMillan, Mack Johnson, Michael Siptroth and I went to Port Orchard and paid $25 traffic tickets for being pedestrians in the roadway at the Trident Base Trigger gate on August 10th. We did this act of civil disobedience on the 70th anniversary of the nuclear bombing of 2 Japanese cities- Hiroshima & Nagasaki. Our action impeded the flow of a thousand cars – driven by workers at the Trident Sub base, homeport for a substantial proportion of the United States strategic nuclear bombs. Thousands of workers saw us holding up a sign that said, “We can all live without Trident.” After our arrest several of us were thanked by one of the Marines guarding the base entry. The civil disobedience was a deeply courteous, successful and moving event.

Doug (at far left) during the August blockade as State Patrol officers move resisters off the roadway. (photo by Glen Milner)

Doug (at far left) during the August blockade as Sheriff and State Patrol officers move resisters off the roadway. (photo by Glen Milner)

In early August Jefferson County residents Brenda McMillan, Kit Simian and I had joined other activists living in Puget Sound for several days at The Ground Zero center for Nonviolent Resistance located next to the Trident base. I was among kindred spirits who focus on waking the people, and protecting our ability to live on this planet. After much consideration I decided that blocking traffic, and having to pay a pedestrian in the roadway fine would be a reasonable and decent life-affirming act. Kit and others risk a 6 month federal sentence by laying down on the road and sprinkling ashes around their bodies, leaving an outline similar to what was left of people who were vaporized by the nukes used in Japan.

Judge Steve Olsen of the Kitsap district court reduced our fines from $63, and thanked us for what we had done. When it was my turn to speak in front of the judge I talked about what a nuclear attack on the Trident base would be like, where I believe multiple thermonuclear bombs are targeted. Hundreds of thousands of us dead, our hospitals destroyed, Seattle in ruins, vast amounts of radioactive fallout, a f______ nightmare.

The likelihood of a nuclear war at this moment in time is substantial. Currently NATO is playing a war game in Europe called “Trident Juncture 2015” practicing for an all-out war, with the military industries of 15 countries participating. Our government has declared economic war on Russia, Russia is bombing the terrorists we have been incubating in Syria. Missile launch pads are being built in the Ukraine. The nuclear noose around Russia is being tightened. We’re talking brinksmanship people! The noose is around our necks as well.

I am one of thousands questioning the latest round of military growth here in Puget Sound. When I hear the growlers, airplanes designed to detect and destroy radar systems, I know that a nuclear war is being prepared and is practiced for daily. I think of the military not so much as servants of our freedom, but rather part of the military industrial congressional media drug thug complex. War is very profitable for a few, and a job for many thousands of us. Our government is constantly sowing seeds of war. More guns, bombs, planes, subs must be sold, the empire must have control of oil, the global marketplace must be in dollars, military full spectrum dominance must be upgraded, all paid for by borrowing money our children will have to pay so that the 1/10th of 1% billionaire class that that owns capitalism inc. can rule the world.

Being arrested for Peace is an honor. Helping the coming lawsuit that will challenge the Navy’s abuse of the Environmental Impact Statement process is a duty. Come together! We can change the direction the rulers of the world are headed (dead end). In the names of our grandchildren let’s claim the power to survive! We are many and all of us want a world that is not at the edge of destruction.

Doug's wife Nancy (holding grandaughter Inez) and daughter Amanda (photo by Gabe Van Lelyveld)

Doug’s wife Nancy (holding granddaughter Inez) and daughter Amanda  (photo by Gabe Van Lelyveld)

 

Share widely